{
  "source": "Reconora Research, one anonymised merchant day",
  "report": "https://reconora.com/payment-chaos",
  "version": "1.1",
  "updated": "2026-10-18",
  "note": "One anonymised merchant day: a single observation, not an industry benchmark. Structural figures only; no money amounts; the merchant and its providers are not named. Scope \"full day\" = every message of the day; \"reconciliation scope\" = the merchant’s deposit log reconciled with notifications and statements.",
  "terms": "You may quote these figures with a link to https://reconora.com/payment-chaos.",
  "facts": {
    "providers_live": {
      "label": "Payment providers with traffic in the day",
      "value": 96,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "currencies_day": {
      "label": "Currencies seen in the day",
      "value": 29,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "records_day": {
      "label": "Records read (log lines and provider messages)",
      "value": 1526847,
      "display": "1.5 million",
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "records_parsed": {
      "label": "Records parsed into events",
      "value": 1187215,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "records_skipped": {
      "label": "Records skipped by rule (not provider data)",
      "value": 329997,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "records_quarantined": {
      "label": "Records quarantined with a reason",
      "value": 9635,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "quarantine_share_pct": {
      "label": "Share of records quarantined",
      "value": 0.6,
      "unit": "percent of records",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "events_day": {
      "label": "Events after parsing",
      "value": 790948,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "transactions_day": {
      "label": "Transactions after folding events",
      "value": 318804,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "duplicate_observations": {
      "label": "Repeated observations of the same fact folded",
      "value": 401255,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "message_forms": {
      "label": "Distinct message shapes",
      "value": 1198,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "message_families": {
      "label": "Message families",
      "value": 831,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "key_paths": {
      "label": "Distinct JSON key paths",
      "value": 3110,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "forms_per_provider_max": {
      "label": "Most message shapes at one provider",
      "value": 41,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "providers_with_callbacks": {
      "label": "Providers sending notifications (callbacks)",
      "value": 66,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "status_paths": {
      "label": "Distinct JSON paths carrying a status",
      "value": 39,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "status_raw_values": {
      "label": "Distinct raw status values",
      "value": 318,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "status_canonical_used": {
      "label": "Canonical status meanings used",
      "value": 9,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "amount_rules_major": {
      "label": "Message rules with amounts in major units",
      "value": 190,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "amount_rules_minor": {
      "label": "Message rules with amounts in minor units",
      "value": 51,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "time_formats": {
      "label": "Time formats in provider timestamps",
      "value": 5,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "families_total": {
      "label": "Message types (families) configured",
      "value": 278,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "families_with_provider_time": {
      "label": "Message types carrying the provider’s own timestamp",
      "value": 32,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "error_codes_raw": {
      "label": "Distinct raw error codes",
      "value": 135,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "error_codes_unified": {
      "label": "Unified error codes used",
      "value": 15,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "error_pairs": {
      "label": "Distinct provider × error-code pairs",
      "value": 211,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "statement_formats": {
      "label": "Statement formats configured",
      "value": 35,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "stmt_lines_without_our_id_pct": {
      "label": "Statement lines without the merchant’s ID",
      "value": 54.2,
      "unit": "percent of statement lines",
      "scope": "full day"
    },
    "share_matched_pct": {
      "label": "Turnover matched (confirmed by statements)",
      "value": 75.9,
      "unit": "percent of turnover",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "share_awaiting_pct": {
      "label": "Turnover awaiting a statement",
      "value": 12.6,
      "unit": "percent of turnover",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "share_money_pct": {
      "label": "Turnover that differs in money",
      "value": 0.1,
      "unit": "percent of turnover",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "share_facts_pct": {
      "label": "Turnover that differs in facts",
      "value": 1.3,
      "unit": "percent of turnover",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "share_nothing_pct": {
      "label": "Turnover with nothing to reconcile against",
      "value": 10.1,
      "unit": "percent of turnover",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "reversed_outcome": {
      "label": "Payments declined in the log, successful in the statement",
      "value": 320,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "reversed_outcome_other": {
      "label": "Payments successful in the log, not in the statement",
      "value": 61,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "statement_only": {
      "label": "Payments in a statement with no record in the log",
      "value": 317,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "missing_in_statement": {
      "label": "Payments missing from the statement",
      "value": 51,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "discrepancies_day": {
      "label": "Payments in the discrepancy queue",
      "value": 809,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "no_final_status": {
      "label": "Payments without a final status",
      "value": 14191,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "deposit_transactions_scope": {
      "label": "Deposit transactions in the reconciliation scope",
      "value": 114065,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "providers_without_statement": {
      "label": "Providers that sent no statement",
      "value": 26,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "spreadsheet_found_pct": {
      "label": "Log IDs a spreadsheet lookup finds in statements",
      "value": 75.5,
      "unit": "percent of reconciliation lines",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "truly_reconciled_pct": {
      "label": "Lines truly reconciled (ID, amount and outcome agree)",
      "value": 74.4,
      "unit": "percent of reconciliation lines",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "found_but_wrong": {
      "label": "Lines found by lookup but differing in amount or outcome",
      "value": 690,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "incomplete_statement_lines": {
      "label": "Lines affected by incomplete statements",
      "value": 830,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "day_edge_lines": {
      "label": "Lines at the day edge",
      "value": 464,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "incomplete_story_log": {
      "label": "One provider: successful payments in the log",
      "value": 1207,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "incomplete_story_stmt": {
      "label": "One provider: lines in its statement",
      "value": 314,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "incomplete_story_pct": {
      "label": "One provider: share of its payments in its statement",
      "value": 26,
      "unit": "percent",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "claim_candidates": {
      "label": "Claim candidates",
      "value": 11,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "claim_payments": {
      "label": "Payments in claim candidates",
      "value": 128,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "reconciliation scope"
    },
    "decline_codes": {
      "label": "Provider × decline-code pairs",
      "value": 113,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "declines analysis"
    },
    "decline_reasons": {
      "label": "Decline reasons in one dictionary",
      "value": 22,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "declines analysis"
    },
    "decline_provider_fault_pct": {
      "label": "Declines caused by the provider",
      "value": 8.7,
      "unit": "percent of declines",
      "scope": "declines analysis"
    },
    "decline_merchant_fixable_pct": {
      "label": "Declines the merchant can fix",
      "value": 6.9,
      "unit": "percent of declines",
      "scope": "declines analysis"
    },
    "decline_unproven_pct": {
      "label": "Declines with an unproven reason",
      "value": 42.5,
      "unit": "percent of declines",
      "scope": "declines analysis"
    },
    "incident_failure_pct": {
      "label": "Failure rate of one provider during one incident hour",
      "value": 22.2,
      "unit": "percent of payments",
      "scope": "declines analysis"
    },
    "top_providers_count": {
      "label": "Providers carrying most transactions",
      "value": 18,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "provider map"
    },
    "tail_providers_count": {
      "label": "Providers in the long tail",
      "value": 49,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "provider map"
    },
    "top_share_pct": {
      "label": "Share of transactions carried by the top providers",
      "value": 90,
      "unit": "percent of transactions",
      "scope": "provider map"
    },
    "tail_share_pct": {
      "label": "Share of transactions in the long tail",
      "value": 10,
      "unit": "percent of transactions",
      "scope": "provider map"
    },
    "anon_minutes": {
      "label": "Anonymisation time for the day’s logs",
      "value": 40.3,
      "unit": "minutes",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "anon_residual_pii": {
      "label": "Residual personal data found after anonymisation",
      "value": 0,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_email_pct": {
      "label": "Planted e-mail markers removed",
      "value": 100,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_phone_pct": {
      "label": "Planted phone markers removed",
      "value": 100,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_card_pct": {
      "label": "Planted card-number markers removed",
      "value": 100,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_iban_pct": {
      "label": "Planted IBAN markers removed",
      "value": 100,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_ip_pct": {
      "label": "Planted IP-address markers removed",
      "value": 100,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_name_pct": {
      "label": "Planted name markers removed",
      "value": 99.1,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_documents_pct": {
      "label": "Planted document numbers without a marker word removed",
      "value": 26.4,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "marker_threshold_pct": {
      "label": "Release threshold for each marker type",
      "value": 95,
      "unit": "percent of markers",
      "scope": "anonymiser test"
    },
    "onboard_machine_minutes": {
      "label": "Machine time from raw logs to first result",
      "value": 63.1,
      "unit": "minutes",
      "scope": "onboarding run"
    },
    "onboard_logs_minutes": {
      "label": "Machine time: anonymising logs",
      "value": 40.3,
      "unit": "minutes",
      "scope": "onboarding run"
    },
    "onboard_statements_minutes": {
      "label": "Machine time: anonymising statements",
      "value": 2.9,
      "unit": "minutes",
      "scope": "onboarding run"
    },
    "onboard_engine_minutes": {
      "label": "Machine time: engine run",
      "value": 17.3,
      "unit": "minutes",
      "scope": "onboarding run"
    },
    "onboard_recon_minutes": {
      "label": "Machine time: reconciliation",
      "value": 0.1,
      "unit": "minutes",
      "scope": "onboarding run"
    },
    "message_primitives": {
      "label": "Primitives in every payment message (concept)",
      "value": 8,
      "unit": "count",
      "scope": "concept"
    }
  }
}
